[quote author=676B6E70716E7B1E0 link=1255539933/38#38 date=1258331395]Well, I am happy that you have found a away to cope with the pain you have. I am also happy you have isolated what food that trigger the pain for you.
So then....are you saying those who claim food triggers are NOT misdiagnosed?
No. I am saying that there are pain conditions that are related to your dietary intake. Note that I do not use the term CH.
Without resorting to the same style of rethoric. Perhaps I was a bit unclear, what I meant is that I have not seen any indication of food being a trigger in any of the articles/papers I've read about CH. I have, however seen indications that alcohol might trigger CH...and what else yes, nitroglycerine - but you don't consume that so frequently.
Not sure what rhetoric you are speaking of...it was a simple question.
Well, it is a common rethoric at least on the internet, to question peoples references etc. I could have turned it all around and done the same, but it wouldn't amount to anything useful.
Would suggest you read the archives of this site...lots of folks indicating food triggers (and yup, some NOT)...
When I mentioned papers/articles - I am not referring to some post on some forum. I can probably dig up some source references.
Yes, I guess that was kind of a lowblow from my part. I am just thinking that given that I haven't read anything about food being a trigger - then you start to wonder if the researchers are wrong, the diagnoses are wrong - or perhaps it's a mix.
What isn't known about ch could fill a library....research and diagnosis may and probably are wrong or nonexistent...we are waiting (desperately) for something...anything. Again...read the archives.
..
Actually, from my point of view there seems to be quite a lot specific symptoms that can be used to do a fairly good diagnosis. I do not think there is a lack in that department. I do however agree that as to the cause or treatment, there is a lot to be desired. I still do not believe the archives are or should be the primary source of information as to what should be considered CH or not.
[snipping some stuff]
Not following the logic here....if ch is anything...it is consistent with its inconsistency...the beast morphs and takes many forms. YES, nearly everyone here has been misdiagnosed at some point or the other...the fact we have different triggers doesn't mean we don't have ch. Sheesh...I am at a loss to express this better....can you help me?
Well, then we are in agreement. Alot of people here and elsewhere are misdiagnosed. Yes, I understand the condition may change over time. I for one have been lucky and my episodes have decreased in frequency, but then became stable at the current rate. (for which I am happy.)
Sure, I know I am not very knowledgable - but from what I've read parameters like intensity, frequency, cyclelength, attacklength and treatment efficiency, vary tremendously. That is perhaps one of the worst parts - that it might change on you any day.
However I have yet to read one single CH specialist/researcher that indicates that there is a dietary causation. If you know of any such research I would be very grateful to get a link or at least the paper name with author - because then it would mean that I have misunderstood what little I think I have learnt about CH.
Because as you pointed out - much is unknown. It might turn out that there is a link and some researcher will find or has found it. Then I will repent and change my position.
[snip again]
Misdiagnosis seems to be a hotpoint with you....NO argument there....we know that shite.....and then moved on...
Well, yes it is a hotpoint. I did not get any proper help during my teens, which made them very hard from a coping perspective. I feel that the doctors I met had too little knowledge and tended to just group together all headaches.
When I was in the waitingroom at my current doctor I found a book about the different types of headaches they know about. It was perhaps 350 pages of dense medical stuff. Some of it was treatable, some of it was not.
If you have something cureable and get misdiagnosed with something incureable that is really bad. So you could say it is a hotpoint.
...let it go bro'...forgive and/or forget
Sure. I am not riled up or angry about this. I am merely making my position clear - I am not aware of any research that indicates any dietary intake as a CH trigger.
BR,
void