Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register
Clusterheadaches.com
 
Search box updated Dec 3, 2011... Search ch.com with Google!
  HomeHelpSearchLoginRegisterEvent CalendarBirthday List  
 





Page Index Toggle Pages: 1
Send Topic Print
Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH? (Read 8284 times)
Lieutenant2
CH.com Newbie
*
Offline


I Love CH.com!


Posts: 18
Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Oct 29th, 2010 at 3:47pm
 
So, I stumbled across a threaded discussion (elsewhere) wherein a nutritionist was talking about a link between vegetarian/vegan diets and depression (mostly in women, but he was making a blanket statement). He was citing a lack of natural tryptophan in his theory, along with B-12, iron, and some other meat-happy chemicals.

What caught my eye was his assertion that vegetarian diets can interfere with sleep patterns, brain function, serotonin levels, and the hypothalmus. Hmmmm. . .

It got me thinking. My first bout with this crap came a few months after I went total vegetarian. I'm not saying there's a direct corellation at all, but has anyone else had a similar experience? Or has there been any discussion along these lines? Just reaching for something, like we so often do. I'm not going back to eating meat any time soon!
Back to top
  
 
IP Logged
 
Potter
CH.com Alumnus
***
Offline


Team MOOSE DROOL Stinky
Stuff on a Hook Prostaff


Posts: 3600
Blgs.Mt.
Gender: male
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #1 - Oct 29th, 2010 at 5:12pm
 
Lieutenant2 wrote on Oct 29th, 2010 at 3:47pm:
So, I stumbled across a threaded discussion (elsewhere) wherein a nutritionist was talking about a link between vegetarian/vegan diets and depression (mostly in women, but he was making a blanket statement). He was citing a lack of natural tryptophan in his theory, along with B-12, iron, and some other meat-happy chemicals.

What caught my eye was his assertion that vegetarian diets can interfere with sleep patterns, brain function, serotonin levels, and the hypothalmus. Hmmmm. . .

It got me thinking. My first bout with this crap came a few months after I went total vegetarian. I'm not saying there's a direct corellation at all, but has anyone else had a similar experience? Or has there been any discussion along these lines? Just reaching for something, like we so often do. I'm not going back to eating meat any time soon!

   I'll eat yours.

        Potter
Back to top
  
 
IP Logged
 
Guiseppi
CH.com Moderator
CH.com Alumnus
*****
Offline


San Diego to Florida 05-16-2011


Posts: 12063
SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA USA
Gender: male
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #2 - Oct 29th, 2010 at 5:21pm
 
There have been a lot of threads on supplements....vitamins,minerals, testosterone therapy, and of course we all talk about food as triggers for some, but I do not recall having seen anyone with a vegan diet that's managed to ditch CH yet! (not counting Neil who shows up every 3-4 months trying to convince us 3000mg of Vitamin D a day cures CH! Wink)

That being said, if any change in your life style decreases either the frequency or the severity of your CH, run with it as long as it carries you!

Joe
Back to top
  

"Somebody had to say it" is usually a piss poor excuse to be mean.
 
IP Logged
 
Lieutenant2
CH.com Newbie
*
Offline


I Love CH.com!


Posts: 18
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #3 - Oct 29th, 2010 at 7:05pm
 
Nah, Joe. . .it's actually the other way around! I started on the CH train at roughly the same time I went vegetarian, so I'm sure as hell not finding and relief! I'm not planning to go back to being a carnivore, for other health reasons. . .but this guy was saying that being vegetarian can cause major issues with serotonin, hypothalamus, etc.

I was just wondering if there were any other veg-heads here? No? Beuller? Beuller?


Back to top
  
 
IP Logged
 
Callico
CH.com Hall of Famer
*****
Offline


Author of "Stranded at
Romson's Lodge


Posts: 4916
Aurora IL
Gender: male
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #4 - Oct 29th, 2010 at 7:59pm
 
Eat meat or not, you're still a clusterhead.  It isn't the meat or lack thereof.  However, I don't doubt living as a vegan might have implications on other issues.

Man was not designed to be vegan though.  Take a good look at your teeth.  Humans don't have the amount of enamel on their teeth herbivores have. 

Just my $.02 for what it's worth.

Jerry
Back to top
  

"Political correctness is a doctrine, fostered by a delusional, illogical minority, and rabidly promoted by an unscrupulous mainstream media, which holds forth the proposition that it is entirely possible to pick up a piece of dung by the clean end." Texas A&M Student (unknown)
Jerry Callison  
IP Logged
 
Lieutenant2
CH.com Newbie
*
Offline


I Love CH.com!


Posts: 18
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #5 - Oct 29th, 2010 at 8:11pm
 
C'mon, Jerry. . .I was thinking a little deeper than that! As in, lack of tryptophan in a diet leading to CH? Low amounts of B-vitamins, maybe? I'm certainly not going to debate the merits of eating meat / not eating meat here, just wondering if I'm the only vegetarian in the world who started getting CH around the same time he/she stopped eating meat?

But you should pick up a copy of Michael Pollen's book, "The Omnivore's Dilemma", anyway. It's a great read!   Smiley
Back to top
  
 
IP Logged
 
bejeeber
CH.com Hall of Famer
*****
Offline




Posts: 1359
Gnashville
Gender: male
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #6 - Oct 29th, 2010 at 8:24pm
 
I'm a vegetarian CH'er who doesn't buy into the old "look at your teeth" carnivore arguments, but anyway I imagine I'm one of the very few vegetarians here, which is one reason I'm skeptical that it can have any sway on CH.

Otherwise I suppose this place would be full of vegetarians. I never thought for a moment that Potter might be one.  Grin
Back to top
« Last Edit: Oct 29th, 2010 at 9:25pm by bejeeber »  

CH according to Bejeeber:

Strictly relying on doctors for CH treatment is often a prescription that will keep you in a whole lot of PAIN. Doctors are WAY behind in many respects, and they are usually completely unaware of the benefits of high flow 100% O2.

There are lots of effective treatments documented at this site. Take matters into your own hands, learn as much as you can here and at clusterbusters.com, put it into practice, then tell this CH beast Jeebs said hello right before you bash him so hard with a swift uppercut knockout punch that his stupid horns go flinging right off.
bejeeber bejeeber Enter your address line 1 here  
IP Logged
 
JustNotRight
CH.com Sponsor
***
Offline


CH version 15.0.8 member
since 2005 aka GingerS224


Posts: 1300
Wilkes-Barre, Pa (USA)
Gender: female
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #7 - Oct 29th, 2010 at 10:11pm
 
bejeeber wrote on Oct 29th, 2010 at 8:24pm:
Otherwise I suppose this place would be full of vegetarians. I never thought for a moment that Potter might be one.  Grin

That ain't lettuce in his freezer... I never knew how much Buffalo meat one could cram into a freezer  Cheesy
_____________________________

Still have CH and I'm Not Vegan or Vegetarian I eat a healthy diet of meats veggies and grains light on the dairy  Tongue
Back to top
  

Multimedia File Viewing and Clickable Links are available for Registered Members only!!  You need to Login or Register
An eye for eye only ends up making the whole world blind.
M.K. Gandhi

If you are going through hell...Just keep going
WWW JustNotRight gngr.stewart GingerS224  
IP Logged
 
Brew
CH.com Sponsor
CH.com Alumnus
***
Offline




Posts: 14163
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #8 - Oct 29th, 2010 at 10:55pm
 
I was a vegetarian from age 24 to age 30. Full-fledged carnivore before and since. CH started when I was 28.
Back to top
  

"I have been asked if I have changed in these past 25 years. No, I am the same. Only more so."  --Ayn Rand
 
IP Logged
 
wimsey1
CH.com Alumnus
***
Offline


I Love CH.com!


Posts: 2457
MA
Gender: male
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #9 - Oct 30th, 2010 at 7:13am
 
There might be something to the Vitamin B thing. I posted a thread about vitamin B6 being necessary to the production of melatonin, a precursor for GABA, and how taurine eats up B6. A lot of the B vitamins (like niacin) are part of a chain that is involved in neural health. I take a super B complex every day, and while I don't know if it did anything by itself, in combo with other things I'm not going to stop, it seems to help. Anyway, bite the bullet and and a turkey sandwich and see if you get better. You can always go vegan again later. Or, try the B complex thingie. Blessings! lance
Back to top
  
 
IP Logged
 
bejeeber
CH.com Hall of Famer
*****
Offline




Posts: 1359
Gnashville
Gender: male
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #10 - Oct 30th, 2010 at 9:37pm
 
Hey Lieutenant2, if yout're the sort of vegetarian who eats eggs and dairy, there's plenty of B12 to be found there.

And nuts, seeds, beans are the go to items for tryptophan.
Back to top
  

CH according to Bejeeber:

Strictly relying on doctors for CH treatment is often a prescription that will keep you in a whole lot of PAIN. Doctors are WAY behind in many respects, and they are usually completely unaware of the benefits of high flow 100% O2.

There are lots of effective treatments documented at this site. Take matters into your own hands, learn as much as you can here and at clusterbusters.com, put it into practice, then tell this CH beast Jeebs said hello right before you bash him so hard with a swift uppercut knockout punch that his stupid horns go flinging right off.
bejeeber bejeeber Enter your address line 1 here  
IP Logged
 
Shuli
CH.com Junior
**
Offline


I Love CH.com!


Posts: 36
New York, NY
Gender: female
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #11 - Oct 31st, 2010 at 11:06am
 
I've been thinking a bit about all these little symptoms that might combine to form the perfect storm.

Had my first attack last year at age 32 - and back then was eating meat about 2x / month.  Even though I eat more meat now, this year's cycle was A LOT worse.

I'm slightly hypothyroid, and I just had blood work done during my last CH cycle indicating that I'm also slightly anemic.
Which means that my blood is not able to deliver an adequate amount of oxygen.
Iron, found in meant, helps with this!  Of course, Iron can be found elsewhere.
But I don't doubt that there is a connection between lack of oxygen triggering or causing a suitable environment for an attack. I doubt it causes CH on its own -

Make sure you eat well!  and take good care of yourself.
there's an excellent cookbook that I swear by:
How to Cook Everything Vegetarian
Multimedia File Viewing and Clickable Links are available for Registered Members only!!  You need to Login or Register"

And actually, a few more about cooking with whole foods which might help:

Multimedia File Viewing and Clickable Links are available for Registered Members only!!  You need to Login or Register

Multimedia File Viewing and Clickable Links are available for Registered Members only!!  You need to Login or Register

Bon Apetite, pain free of course!
Back to top
  
 
IP Logged
 
Lieutenant2
CH.com Newbie
*
Offline


I Love CH.com!


Posts: 18
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #12 - Oct 31st, 2010 at 3:18pm
 
Thanks Shuli. . .some excellent info there! I'm especially interested in the stuff on whole foods, I've been trying to go locavore/whole foods as much as possible. So, THANKS!

I also gave a quick thought to possible iron deficiency, so I had bloodwork done (haven't we all?) Everything normal there, and I think my diet is pretty balanced with iron-rich foods.

I seriously don't think I have any nutritional deficiencies at all. I'm in very good physical shape, I feel great, etc. I was just trying to go down the rabbit hole of B6 and tryptophan that was mentioned elsewhere, but I'm probably getting plenty of those, too.

Eh, it was worth a shot!
Back to top
  
 
IP Logged
 
Kate in Oz
CH.com Hall of Famer
*****
Offline




Posts: 633
Australia
Gender: female
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #13 - Oct 31st, 2010 at 6:33pm
 
Hi,

I started CH when I was about 18/19, went vegetarian around 20 (after reading Peter Singer's book 'Animal Liberation' - changed my life  Wink), now 41 and have been eating some fish only since I had my son 8 yrs ago.  I don't know if it affects my CH, they have changed a lot in the past few years - less intense hits/more shadows.  I'm putting that down to better management and maybe just maybe because I'm getting older....

I have suffered from depression in the past but rather than diet I'd have to put that down to life situations and possible family history of depression....   I also suffer from fibromyalgia which is not great - but again have not read anywhere that that is connected to diet....

I think being vegetarian (hard to call myself that these days due to the fish but anyway) produces many more health benefits than deficites - and makes me personally feel better about my global footprint etc etc

Not sure that any of that is helpful to you....  kinda nice to know that there are a couple of other vegies about tho'  Smiley

Kate
Back to top
  
339600790  
IP Logged
 
Katherinecm
CH.com Sponsor
***
Offline




Posts: 432
Des Moines, IA, USA
Gender: female
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #14 - Nov 5th, 2010 at 7:05pm
 
Most vegetarians don't have issues with B vitamins- most are found in grains.  B12 comes from bacteria & is only found in significant quantities in animal products, but the bacteria that produce it is also in healthy soil and even your digestive tract (especially if you happen to be the raw-foodie, eat unwashed organic veggies type.  yuck).

I was a vegetarian for years and I've had some hypothyroid issues that exacerbate my CH  (anything that disrupts sleep makes me worse).  I suspect that the highly processed soy foods inherent in modern vegetarian diets have a lot to do with that.   Soy and cruciferous vegetables block iodine, which prevents the thyroid from working properly.

I've read somewhere that old-fashioned asian vegetarian diets don't have that problem  (the soy is fermented and so many sea vegetables are included that dietary iodine is extremely high), but I can't say I've read any studies to that effect, I think it was probably speculation.  At any rate, few vegetarians eat traditional vegetable-based diets.  Most I know eat a lot of sweets and make very little effort to get the RDA for anything.
Back to top
  

"We are not human beings having a spiritual experience. We are spiritual beings that have a human experience."  Teilhard de Chardin
Katherinecm Katherinecm http://www.facebook.com/katym katycatcm katycatcm  
IP Logged
 
msussman
CH.com Newbie
*
Offline




Posts: 24
Tucson, AZ
Gender: male
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #15 - Nov 7th, 2010 at 1:58am
 
Lessee here, I was vegetarian for 4 years starting in high school, then carnivore for 4 years, vegetarian for 6 years after that, carnivore for another 4 years, now back to vegetarianism again.  CH first hit me while I was eating meat and hasn't seemed to change at all with my wacky eating patterns, even when I was flirting with pure veganism.

...and just as a side note for those say "cavemen didn't evolve incisors for eating only veggies", bear in mind early humans had a 50% infant mortality rate and a life expectancy of 35. Living like they did might not be the best idea.
Back to top
  
 
IP Logged
 
Brew
CH.com Sponsor
CH.com Alumnus
***
Offline




Posts: 14163
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #16 - Nov 7th, 2010 at 8:14am
 
But what percentage of modern humans are carnivores, and what is the modern infant mortality rate? And how much of the infant mortality rate can be linked to diet, both then and now?

One thing we have now that they didn't then is called vaccination. There are many other things we have now as well.

I'm just sayin'....
Back to top
  

"I have been asked if I have changed in these past 25 years. No, I am the same. Only more so."  --Ayn Rand
 
IP Logged
 
George
CH.com Moderator
CH.com Alumnus
*****
Offline


Black-Billed Magpie


Posts: 8126
Boise, Idaho USA
Gender: male
Re: Vegetarian, Vegan, and CH?
Reply #17 - Nov 7th, 2010 at 10:13am
 
msussman wrote on Nov 7th, 2010 at 1:58am:
...and just as a side note for those say "cavemen didn't evolve incisors for eating only veggies", bear in mind early humans had a 50% infant mortality rate and a life expectancy of 35. Living like they did might not be the best idea.


I dunno.  We had a pretty good gig as neolithic, omnivorous hunter-gatherers.  Other than the vagaries associated with weather, big hairy critters, and unfriendly neighbors, it was a pretty good life--three hours effort a day on average satisfied ones needs.  There was a lot of time to relax, make stuff, goof off, and invent intrigues and mayhem.

It wasn't until we began to commit agriculture that things went south on us--hierarchical organizations, poor nutrition, laboring from dawn to dusk for "the man", various and increasingly complicated forms of indenture.  You know the drill.  We even managed to persuade ourselves that it was a good thing to work for some fatcat or another until we dropped, and that we liked it.  Very odd.

Of course it's way too late to do anything about it now.  At this point it'll take some sort of technological deus ex machina to restore any sort of balance to our lives, and those who would lose power over the rest would resist it with every fiber of their being.  We're basically screwed.

Not that any of this has anything to do with whether or not we choose to eat our vegetables.   Wink

Best,

George    
Back to top
  

"Whoever loveth me, loveth my hound."  (Thomas More, author of "Utopia", and Chancellor of England.  1477-1535)
WWW George jacox6820 7165032563  
IP Logged
 
Page Index Toggle Pages: 1
Send Topic Print

DISCLAIMER: All information contained on this web site is for informational purposes only.  It is in no way intended to be used as a replacement for professional medical treatment.   clusterheadaches.com makes no claims as to the scientific/clinical validity of the information on this site OR to that of the information linked to from this site.  All information taken from the internet should be discussed with a medical professional!