Welcome to the board Eric. The paion killers tell me your doc is NOT up to date on the treatment of CH. Short of knocking you out, pain killers just won't help with CH.
FIRST and MOST IMPORTANTLY
Follow this link to the medications section of this board and read the post
Multimedia File Viewing and Clickable Links are available for Registered Members only!! You need to

or

It’s a vitamin/mineral/fish oil supplement, all over the counter stuff. It’s up to an 81% success rate of those who try it and respond to the survey so you’re just shooting yourself in the foot if you don’t give it a shot. I’m 3 years pain free on it after a 30 plus year track record with episodic CH. Best of all, it’s healthy for you even without CH!
So all that follows will be worthless I hope……….but still…treating CH is a bit more complex then taking a pill to get rid of your headache. It takes an organized approach, I used a 3 prong approach in the past, haven't needed it since starting the D-3 regimen above.....many have had success using a similar approach.
1: A good prevent med. A med I take daily, while on cycle, to reduce the number and intensity of my attacks. I use lithium, it blocks 60-70% of my attack. Verapamil is the most common first line prevent, topomax also has a loyal following. Some have to combine lithium and verapamil together to get relief. You mentioned verapamil, we tend to take it at doses much higher then most docs are used to. Some have to go as high as 960 mg a day to get relief.
2: A transitional med. Most prevents will take up to 2 weeks to become effective. I go on a prednisone taper, from 80 mg to zero over a two week period to give me a break while my prevent builds up. Prednisone will provide up to 100% relief for many CH’ers but is harsh on the system and should only be used for short periods of time.
3: An abortive therapy, the attack starts, now what? Oxygen should be your first line abortive. Breathing pure 02 will abort an attack for me in less then 10 minutes, that’s completely pain free. Read this link as it must be used correctly or it will not work
Multimedia File Viewing and Clickable Links are available for Registered Members only!! You need to

or

This link will show you how to get set up with welding oxygen:
Multimedia File Viewing and Clickable Links are available for Registered Members only!! You need to

or

Imitrex nasal spray and injectables are very effective abortives. I use the injectables, they’re expensive, and I rarely use them, mostly just when I get caught away from the oxygen. The pill form generally works too slow to be effective for CH’ers.
For now, get some energy drinks. Rock Star, Monster, any containing the combo of caffeine and taurine, chug it down as fast as you can when you feel an attack starting. Many can abort or at least really reduce an attack using these.
Finally, visit our sister board for “alternative” treatment methods outside of mainstream medicine. As you’ll see from all the success stories on this board, there is something to it.
clusterbusters.com
Read everything you can on this board, if you are a CH’er, knowledge is your best ally. We’ll help you all we can.
Joe